David C. Gutwill, owner of Ultimate Car Care in Fair Lawn, NJ is a multiple-time convicted felon currently accused of being an accessory to fraud perpetrated on a 90-year old stroke survivor.
Structured access to verified consumer complaints and public court records associated with Ultimate Car Care in Fair Lawn, NJ, compiled for informational transparency.
David C. Gutwill’s Criminal Convictions
David Gutwill, owner of Ultimate Car Care in Fair Lawn, NJ criminal convictions (per the BeenVerified public records report) stem from a single primary record involving multiple related New Jersey charges, mostly initiated around April 16, 2007, with court dispositions finalized in 2009. The report lists these as one aggregated “Possible Criminal & Traffic Records” entry (1 record total). No other criminal or traffic records appear.
Detailed List of Offenses and Dispositions
All dates refer to offense/arrest/charge dates unless noted as court disposition dates:
- Theft by Deception (value $500–$74,999, involving gun/MV/CDS ≤1kg etc.) Type: Criminal/Traffic Case: 006001426 Date: April 16, 2007 Disposition: Incarcer General
- Money Laundering / Financial Facilitation (NJ statute 2C:21-25*2, 1 count) Type: Criminal/Traffic (also listed as Arrest under case 09-02-00422-I) Case: 06001426 / 000140729B Date: April 16, 2007 Disposition: Incarcer General
- Tampering/Retaliating with Witness/Informant (2C:28-5*3, 1 count) Type: Criminal/Traffic Case: 07-06-01141-I / 000140729B Date: April 16, 2007 Disposition: Related to Incarcer General (and later jail reference)
- Conspiracy Type: Court Case: 009000529 Date: February 25, 2009 (court disposition) Disposition: Guilty
- Tampering with Records (destroy/remove/conceal record etc.) Type: Court Case: 09000529 Date: February 25, 2009 (court disposition) Disposition: Guilty
- Fraud Type: DOC / Criminal/Traffic Case: P652257 Disposition: Sentenced (no specific date beyond the cluster)
Additional references include “Jail” (undated, tied to the above) and repeated entries for the same core offenses.
Overall outcome: David Gutwill was sentenced to “Incarcer General” on the main 2007 financial/obstruction charges and received guilty findings/sentencing on the related counts. Exact sentence length, start/end dates, or parole details are not provided in the report.
Additional Context from Broader Public Records
Public web searches (including NJ court-related sites, case numbers, statutes like 2C:21-25 and 2C:28-5, and name/address variations such as David C. Gutwill of Fort Lee/Moonachie, NJ) turned up no news articles, detailed dockets, or additional convictions. The only external confirmation appears in a 2020 Bergen County, NJ civil lawsuit (D’Antonio v. Gutwill / Ultimate Car Care Inc.), where discovery requests explicitly reference his prior incarceration for “fraud, theft by deception, failure to pay income tax or any other crimes emanating from [his] business” (allegedly filed by his former wife in connection with their divorce). This aligns with the report but adds a possible tax-related element not explicitly listed in the BeenVerified document.
A separate 2009 Chapter 13 bankruptcy (case 0922042RG, filed May 11, 2009, dismissed; debtor David C. Gutwill, Fort Lee, NJ) is noted but is not criminal.
Summary: The convictions center on financial crimes (theft by deception, money laundering, fraud) plus obstruction (witness tampering, record tampering, conspiracy), resulting in incarceration. No evidence of further criminal history appears in available public sources. All details are drawn directly from the provided BeenVerified PDF and cross-checked against public records (as of current search data). Note that public record aggregators like BeenVerified are not official court sources and may not reflect full, updated, or expunged information.